DM Toolbox: 10 Plot Hooks for Pirate-Themed Campaigns
Honestly, the best ships glow in the dark.
Pirates, sea monsters, and cursed treasure— my kind of party! Pirate-themed campaigns are beloved for their swashbuckling action and high-stakes exploration. Whether you're running a nautical one-shot or a full campaign set in storm-tossed seas, you need hooks to get your players invested. Below are 10 plot hooks perfect for kicking off your next pirate adventure or injecting drama mid-voyage.
1. The Map with No X
A local drunkard sells the party a tattered treasure map with no clear destination. The only clue? The map changes each night based on the phases of the moon. Is it cursed? Magical? Or a trap?
2. Whispers from the Deep
Strange singing echoes from beneath the waves, luring sailors to their doom. A sea god’s prison may be cracking open—and the party has caught its attention.
3. The Ghost Ship Pact
A merchant vessel, long believed lost, sails back into port—without a crew. When boarded, the ship reveals strange, otherworldly cargo and a spectral logbook begging for help.
4. The Duel of Captains
A legendary pirate captain dies, leaving behind not one, but two wills—each naming a different heir. The rivals call upon the party to prove their legitimacy by hunting down the fabled Sea Fang relic.
5. Plague in the Port
A seaside town is under lockdown. Ships arriving show no signs of life, but their hulls drip with a glowing, blue moss. The locals say it’s the work of the "Coral Curse."
6. The Kraken Cult
Rumors swirl of a cult worshipping a kraken beneath the coral reef. When sacrifices begin disappearing from neighboring islands, the party must dive deep—both literally and figuratively.
7. The Leviathan's Debt
A merchant lord hires the players to retrieve a chest from a sunken vault. The vault lies inside the belly of a leviathan that once made a pact with pirates for safe passage—until someone broke the deal.
8. The Floating Market
Once every decade, a black market made entirely of linked rafts and ships appears on the open sea. Rumors say it holds the key to eternal youth—if you survive long enough to leave.
9. Sails of Flame
A fire-ship crewed by fire genasi pirates is attacking coastal towns. Their ship leaves no survivors—but always spares one dockhand or deckhand with a warning to deliver. What are they searching for?
10. The Siren's Toll
A new sea passage opens, cutting travel time by weeks. But the toll? A “gift” left on the water every voyage: gold, blood, or a song. Fail to pay, and your ship is pulled under by unseen hands.
Want More?
Check out our actual play sessions and more content at RollDFive.com.
Be sure to check out our list of top items to use in a Pirate themed setting here.